jmh132 wrote:
The ratings are not yet used to break ties. If we start getting enough data that appears meaningful then we will start using it for that. If it stays inconsistant then we wont. Remember, this is a proposed solution for the nay-sayers of the current tie-breaking system, some of whom are already dismissing this just a few days in.
Not being an advantage member yet I realise that there is no weight behind my moaning.
I moaned about the current system in a topic i raised a few weeks ago and I think that using the ratings as a tie break is just totally flawed.
Another way of settling it would be to have a tie breaking one-on-one vote off, not dismilar to the tournament system ?
come on. I could live with a 6 cause I messed up the shadows (being to dark) but a 4? and this is only one example. Either people are purposly rating people low, or the general public has no clue how much work went into these things. Unless its terrible, no one should get under a 6 out of 10, getting a 4 is like getting a D in school 
