But if it had come up with a convincing gestalt, would it have been worthy?

If he had put a sardine head on the missle, I would've voted for it...

aghhh rayray killed this thread... good job rayray

this would explain so much because i looked at it thinking wow, but now i see that almost none is his own work.

Damn R (squared) you ever thought of going into private investigation......as they say on mythbusters ...i think its obvious this is busted and yes I agree over voted !!!




...NOW WE ALL KNOW............................... .....NOTHING gets by the REY MAN !!!

YOU GO BOY ....I LOVE IT!!!..the tribe has spoken!!

Im off like a prom dress!!

5150

So the finial verdict is, its a great picture, it just happens to be someone elses work :p

[quote="roy Green"]Look at this contest entry

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115526/votes.html

I think this is great, like one of the best entered, when i went to check how it had done i expected to see it near the top, not with just 10 votes. Can anyone exp

all things considered it was fortunate to get 10 votes (including one from myself)

here's a few entries that I think REALLY were undervoted

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/109179/snowboarders-3d.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/106261/k-e-e-p--o-u-t-.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/105504/mount-rushmore.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/106785/xtreme-stannah.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/105384/standing-stoned.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/105567/holiday-brochure-1983.html
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/104815/man-about-town.html


now I bid you good day...good day I said !!!

No.The final verdict is it was an ok chop as far as anything goes. He got the votes he got and that is that.
Nobody was busted cause nobody did anything wrong .
Picking on the new guy who never did nobody wrong.Priceless.

New guy,
Alls I can say, and God knows Im gonna hear it now is that the voting in here is like a chick.......yeah a female .....ya know fulL of estrogen!......An UNPREDICTABLE AS HELL........Just when ya think ya have it all figured out whammo Bam ....Badda Bing .....
You are thrown the proverbial curve ball and caught so off guard you dont know which way is up....trust me my friend ...someday soon you will have that deja vu feeling when your posts are putting up great numbers and some other new~B is wondering why his aren't and yours are......hey forget about the freaking votes....learn...make friends...(Tip (in cash forum replies to your posts) and most of all have fun damn it....now go have some fun ....and STFUAC.....

Oh BTW were ya told of the rookie rules of 2007........$5.00 to all members here longer than a year...10 for more than 2 etc etc etc or a date with your cute older sister which ever is easiest .....(pun intended)...

Bwahahahahahahhah

Grasshopper ...when you can walk the rice paper and leave no trace( and put chops up Like my buddy Marco or R squared) then you will have learned!!!

5150.............AM I MENTAL?????

people vote on what they like not on skill i mean.. look at this..

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115477/kidnapped.html
no whales in sight complete clean up... background had to be made from imagination...


verses this more voted images which cannot have taken five minutes.

yes i know stock paste and mask done...

(a little shadow goes along way especially when its clearly wrong...)
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115474/index.html

(i mean this guys foot must be in extreame pain... i mean half of his right foot is missing *which is indicative of the wand tool...*(thats our left for the slower folk)
http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115389/family-picture.html

You cant complain... just chop and like it (your portfolio is what yourb building and maybe just maybe sombody may favorate your work... on its own merit...) its all ya can do...

or maybe you can ask everyone to vote for your work....

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115428/votes.html
and heres somthing want to know what this got beaten by...

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115423/votes.html

yes oh my god how simple... its such a poor paste job you can even see all the mistakes with angle perspective...

you never learn, will ya...

i have a learning curve its just a straight line thats all..

[quote="Marx-Man"]people vote on what they like not on skill i mean.. look at this..

http://photoshopcontest.com/view-entry/115477/kidnapped.html
no whales in sight complete clean up... background had to be made from imagination...


ah yes a nice clean up job but don't ya think that water there in front (that wasn't there initially ) has got clone stamp .clone stamp clone stamp...written all over it ?



Just my $ 00.02 worth!!


5150 Am I Mental???

no way has it i thought it read healing brush i better check the font and add more cowbell...

Ignorance is quick to speak.