Photoshop Contest PhotoshopContest.com
Creative Contests. Real Prizes. Essential Resource.
You are not logged in. Log in or Register

 
Photoshop Contest Head to Head Tournament 2011
JORDAN792 vs nifft
winner! votes round compare to
nifft 75 Round #5 original
Winning Image

Voting Details
VoterComment
Zetape Zetape
...
Ammorio Ammorio
...
Rangizzz Rangizzz
The other is good but this just kick ass. Best in the round IMO! I don't think those rays are necessary here.
bud1121 bud1121
nice effect
Salvezza Salvezza
Like the idea of this one....nice job! :)
Heinlein Heinlein
Cool
txpinky txpinky
...
blue_lurker blue_lurker
Ok both very different but this has just got that little extra pop for me. At this level its bloody hard to know where to place your vote. Well done to you both
bogsy bogsy
...
JORDAN792 JORDAN792
great job nifft! this is nice and very good effect. good luck
candyart candyart
...
Krank Krank
...
abraham abraham
very cool, very very nice to look at.
Patre Patre
The Iceman theme and clear reference to source image,in my view, give this image a comparative advantage...
Dream_weaver Dream_weaver
...
Takser3 Takser3
...
screwloose screwloose
...
digimagicnb digimagicnb
Hard choice; this treatment fits subject though icicles are unrealistic
HienTran HienTran
...
annajon annajon
...
seelcraft seelcraft
Nice ice sculpture. Unless it is very thin and hollow, the scene behind it should be more distorted.
gramps gramps
...
thbeghin thbeghin
:)
Tesore Tesore
I like the story is the other 1. This is a beautiful ice sculpture!
Granulated Granulated
...
tadams tadams
...
dewking dewking
...
jcfreak6363 jcfreak6363
...
betdoval betdoval
:)
metalic metalic
...
serious serious
...
Toninn Toninn
...
deshone deshone
good try ...
EJH EJH
...
Tad Tad
...
Eve Eve
Great effort. I think the sun rays aren't necessary. Still a fine image.
Tea Man Tea Man
...
anabe anabe
...
m0nk m0nk
Maybe a tutorial would be useful....
Sleepyeyed Sleepyeyed
...
Sliver Sliver
Ice! Very impressive.. too much going on on the other entry but overall good work!
Napalm32 Napalm32
...
charliesou charliesou
...
captainSMITTY11 captainSMITTY11
would have voted the other way had it just been the girl getting abducted, the lizard thing was quite distracting IMO. some flaws here too but the final image is quite nice. good luck to you both, tough choice
Synthvet Synthvet
...
Totoy Totoy
...
MikeDascola MikeDascola
...
edovan edovan
...
KENNY CHUNG KENNY CHUNG
...
bogonet bogonet
...
Hagen Hagen
Some over-pixellized edges but I like the overall render...! +1
Meeshoo Klan Meeshoo Klan
...
DaVinci DaVinci
...
Trann Trann
...
NButler NButler
...
Designed2522 Designed2522
both of these are really nice however this one takes the cake!!! Great work on both!
Claf Claf
Nice work! Need some distortion of city in transparency. Need also more contrast to feel more shadows (dark blueish) into the ice.
Ivan Roujev Ivan Roujev
...
Eepi Eepi
...
koorio koorio
...
Carcarlo Carcarlo
...
L@rue L@rue
...
glennhanna glennhanna
My favorite of the round.
Dechene Dechene
...
cafn8d cafn8d
Respect to both! trying-to-be-constructive-criticisms: the too-fine and too-numerous icicles and shadow hurt the ice sculpture immensely. And the snow-saucers in the other, to my eye, look like buttons instead of dishes (rounded out instead of in). But ultimately, the ice work trumps the snowsuit-clad creature, however awesome it is.
Jake420 Jake420
awesome only complainant is the icicles on the very bottom and the dark shadow
Lord David Lord David
...
gsenthil gsenthil
...
soulrock soulrock
...
Sh!Za Sh!Za
...
pakimo pakimo
...
madonnemay madonnemay
...
max&roro max&roro
...
:-@dolly :-@dolly
...
hassan.fsp hassan.fsp
.


author votes round compare to
JORDAN792 32 Round #5 original

Voting Details
VoterComment
nifft nifft
well done!!! good luck
billtvshow billtvshow
Eh, this I guess. Pretty thorough source usage. The other looks like a first attempt at following a "turn something to ice" tutorial.
Sjitske Sjitske
nevet nevet
drybie drybie
Azionite Azionite
the202 the202
Grefix Grefix
I have no idea what you eat on a daily basis, but I would suggest to change your diet drastically oO. As for the other one, forgive me if i'm wrong, but although looking very (n)ice, it has too much of a 'step by step tutorial' feel, and too less of you.
ReyRey ReyRey
anfa anfa
badcop badcop
tough decision. I like the story here, though I think the Nike swooshes detract a bit from the image.
nat_g31 nat_g31
Took me some time to come to a decision. I was really close to voting for the other but a couple of things stood out that bugged me. the sun rays seem like they would be better if they were blurred a bit, and the edge of the ice girl seem to jagged and hastily done. This entry seems to have made a bit more effort and looks pretty good even though the lighting and shadows are all over the place.
TheShaman TheShaman
sonic3 sonic3
Good job on both entries, the other is well done on the ice, but i prefer the idea/humour and character on this one. But the shadow doesn't look quite right.
dbbowling dbbowling
volkswes volkswes
rockyjob rockyjob
lol haha :D Great job jordan! Hope this wins!
Tawiskaro Tawiskaro
Tommeken Tommeken
Martrex Martrex
Again I just liked this one better
Cartoon Contractor Cartoon Contractor
Both really cool chops! This one just more entertaining! Well done both of you!
Death of a Clown Death of a Clown
pjsev pjsev
TJ TJ
the burning couch the burning couch
Both show'n quite a bit of effort. This one gets the edge for idea*!
Pearcinator Pearcinator
supak0ma supak0ma
theme and idea vote
UntExp UntExp
bsoholic bsoholic
Goat1981 Goat1981
Love the creativity here. Shadow under the main body needs some work, though it's hard to tell what to do with it as the lighting isn't very defined on the main subject (by the eyes, it looks like from the top and from the left, but the body is evenly lit?). Other is a good conversion to ice, but the idea won me over here. I'm assuming this is Jordan's... You're a toughie. How do you get these ideas? :)
vokaris vokaris
dsclink dsclink


« Go to previous match - back to tournament
Navigate PSC
Contests active  archives  winners  prizes  sponsors  events  rules  rss 
Galleries votes  authentic  skillful  funny  creative  theme  winners 
Interact register  log in/out  forum  chat  user lookup  contact 
Stats monthly leaders  hall of fame  record holders 
PSC advantage  news  (rss)  faq  about  links  contact  home 
Help faq  search  new users  tutorials  contact  password 

Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved.
A venture of ExpertRating.com

PSC Time 12:16 pm EST