| Voter | Comment |
|
kinetic_be
|
|
|
nyxxie
Hmm, I'll go with this one. I luv the worn look for the cup.
|
|
|
Tesore
Nice tiles
|
|
|
janetdog
good
|
|
|
spencej1129
|
|
|
rose-wood71
tiles on table made this stand out for me. writing on centre of cup seems not quite right to me.
|
|
|
Mir
Both are good but this one has that little bit more I think.
|
|
|
bogsy
|
|
|
claudiolky
|
|
|
dannyboyuk09
Best of the two (in my opinion)
|
|
|
Cartoon Contractor
Nice rebuild! The other is good but this one is better!
|
|
|
Starman
|
|
|
ReyRey
Flips coin......You win
|
|
|
Heinlein
|
|
|
spikelmalo
|
|
|
pakimo
Well done :)
|
|
|
blue_lurker
both good a little more effort went into this one
|
|
|
Hagen
Good work here...! Nice idea changing the tiles...! The cup might need some more work though...!
|
|
|
Watch them Drift
not a fan of the table but the other one has too many lighting issues, not that yours doesn't but its the better of the two.
|
|
|
TJ
|
|
|
woobie
|
|
|
buglover
|
|
|
mikey
|
|
|
ihaveissues
|
|
|
volkswes
|
|
|
rockfisch
|
|
|
Tommeken
damn ugly tiles man..but stil nice work ;)
|
|
|
seelcraft
Both created the tiles from other sources or PS, probably smarter than patching them. This one has a truer restoration of the cup, although the front lip is distorted.
|
|
|
Sanctuary
...
|
|
|
Mid
|
|
|
j58roldan
|
|
|
nevet
|
|
|
NButler
|
|
|
JAM
|
|
|
deshone
...
|
|
|
Tad
|
|
|
YerPalAl
Rim is a little problematical, but nice work in general.
|
|
|
anfa
|
|
|
ReinMan
nice tiles!
|
|
|
Janfet
:-)
|
|
|
marcoballistic
A tight one too, I like the crispness of the other, but this has more, the new all source clever tiles are good, and I like the rutic look to the mug, contrasts well with the table
|
|
|
thbeghin
;)
|
|
|
supak0ma
just because the other cup is hovering, the top part of the cup is hideous
|
|
|
DaVinci
Both same idea, not very original but I like this one better...
|
|
|
nifft
|
|
|
|
nifft
|
|
|
the burning couch
Good reconstruct*!
|
|
|
BroChris
nice
|
|
|
MamaBallistic
Love the idea of using the source for the tile pattern! Take more time on your cut outs though. The other entry hasn't optimised the source as you have hence my vote.
|
|
|
glennhanna
Put this cup on your opponent's table, and you've got the best of both chops. The patterns on this cup match the original better relative to size and space, although it appears a little on the thin side.
|
|
|
kbuzz818
nice new table design, that set's yours apart from the ordinary
|
|
|
Tea Man
|
|
|
Pearcinator
The better of the two cleanups. Still not perfect though.
|
|
|
Goat1981
perspective is wonky in the other
|
|
|
jazpur
|
|
|
jefflang007
|
|
|
L@rue
|
|
|
abraham
|
|
|
sonic3
|
|
|
charliesou
|
|
|
bsoholic
|
|
|
cafn8d
I like the new design of the other cup better, but the pattern chosen for the countertop and having it flipped around made this one just a bit more interesting to me. :) Good job to both!
|
|
|
Cambria
|
|
|
soulrock
|
|
|
Claf
|
|
|
mellowdesign
Mug needs work esp. rim...but like what you did with the tiles
|
|
