billtvshow
Two distinct entries, but a very even matchup in the end. The body on the other looks pretty weird, which is about the only flaw. Loving the idea and mood treatment on this one more.
roger1
Very tough choice! I went with this one because of the lighting effects (plus the other entry has the bike stationary but the movement lines are still in the pic)
Designed2522
nice work all around on this entry!!!
sonic3
Like the lighting on this, the other looks awkward.
Goat1981
Great idea here! Clean. Arms, torso, and body position in the other seem awkward, but the idea is really funny. Great work to both. I'm going this way.
glennhanna
I think the other could have been improved if the tentacle looked less cartoonish and more realistic. This one sets a mood and a setting of the past. I like the chalk effect. Overall beautifully executed.
MikeDascola
Both awesome entries!! Good luck to you both.
digimagicnb
Hard choice but prefer this result more
nat_g31
This was a hard choice for me. I think the lighting on the other and the work on the closed door is great. Sadly the only thing that stands out is the poorly integrated ciggy butts that seem too bright and missing the orange tinge they should have. Would have been better without them. I like the humor here and the pretty good execution even if the torso looks to be backwards.
jasper
tentacle should wrap the pin. where is the left shoulder? good work otherwise!
captainSMITTY11
hand is backwards on this one but the other one's darkness makes it impossible to tell how well the clean up was done. I like the humor of the flattened tires and can appreciate the rebuild in this one. Very tough choice good luck to both
Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved. A venture of ExpertRating.com