| Voter | Comment |
|
Tad
|
|
|
nevet
|
|
|
Takser3
|
|
|
JAM
|
|
|
drybie
|
|
|
DaVinci
The other one is a nice image, but I don't see any source photo in there. This entry is all source, and nicely done! :)
|
|
|
TJ
|
|
|
Alex
Idea is amazing, text is totally useless. Whoever you are... ;) (Source too subtle or too absent in the other one)
|
|
|
seelcraft
Simple and a much better use of the source.
|
|
|
gramps
|
|
|
rockyjob
My first idea when I saw the source... Congrats to both contestants these are great.
|
|
|
tadams
|
|
|
Sliver
Love the simplicity and perspective execution! Other entry is beautifully made but I'm dropping my vote on a better use of source.
|
|
|
HienTran
|
|
|
Krank
lots of lighting work here
|
|
|
blindgod
|
|
|
Trann
The other has a nice setting to it but short of the one obvious straw and mushroom caps, the source seems lost. This one's simplicity wins me over.
|
|
|
dewking
|
|
|
Heinlein
Both are great, but this shows more of the source.
|
|
|
jcfreak6363
|
|
|
bsoholic
|
|
|
anabe
|
|
|
sonic3
|
|
|
Tommeken
|
|
|
Zetape
|
|
|
dbbowling
|
|
|
abraham
nice one and good luck Claf!
|
|
|
Eve
One stunning, pull all the stops out entry where source is difficult to find, or a very well made blatant source image. Difficult decision. I'll go with this but kudos to the other.
|
|
|
Michel
Good idea!
|
|
|
the202
|
|
|
KENNY CHUNG
|
|
|
MikeDascola
|
|
|
Azionite
The other is a better idea, but this is better execution hands down.
|
|
|
Hagen
I go for this one although the other looks better by far...! The only thing that bothers me in the other entry though is that the use of the source is not obvious...! This one combines simplicity and neat execution...! Well done...! +1
|
|
|
Dot
|
|
|
TofuTheGreat
Just don't see enough of the source in the other. :-/
|
|
|
vokaris
|
|
|
Granulated
Other one is superb work but has no 'respect' (for want of a more appropriate word) for the source. Sorry Abe.
|
|
|
cafn8d
I like the creativity and source-work in the other, but the execution is much stronger here, to my eye.
|
|
|
screwloose
|
|
|
Grefix
|
|
|
clonestamp trooper
|
|
|
the burning couch
I really like both The idea here may not be so original but the execution....jeezuz...spot on........ The other a really nice image overall even with the low res. bits....soooo......ok...nother coin flip..... *!
|
|
|
EJH
Tough call. Other entry is a very cool image, but I'm struggling with finding a relationship to the source image. I like the simplicity of this one (though would be better w/o the text)
|
|
|
aman
nice clean and awsm wrk .... :)
|
|
|
L@rue
|
|
|
Carrignafoy
|
|
