Some red white and blue rooster versus giant rooster? The color change is well done, but is too safe. This is a much more aggressive idea, with just barely enough execution to make me lean towards it. The cover up should really be much better though.
The cleanup on this one made me vote here, allthough it really needs more work (blurry areas in the cleane up part). Not too sure about the giant rooster thing, doesn't really make sense. As for the other one, I guess it one has some patriotic intention but i fail to see the point and is too simple to do.