I wanted to vote for the other one so bad because of how funny it is, but the more I look the more I realize that it's mostly funny because of the text and not the chopping, which is unfortunately just a little blurry in some areas. I feel this to be interesting and consistent in the foreground aspects, followed by a consistent background. Nice boy/chicken integration as well.
Some chuckles here. The duster is a nice touch. Everything is orderly. The other is a great story with some strong points. The "beak" is a bit forced and looks somewhat out of place. The feather integration is weak in spots. Both good, but this one is better executed, imo.
lol, nice work Pearcinator! Love the creativity. Since I am commenting on all I will just say that the light source seems a bit off but still well done and probably the winner! So congrats and good luck!