Nice cleanup on the other, but the right side of drawers needs a fresh coat of paint. I like the floor mixed into sand. This looks more fun and imaginative for the boring source used, so it gets my vote.
I'm going to have to go with this one.
I love a good clean up but it requires attention to detail: a shadow gradient across the closed drawer surfaces to better match both neighbours (or repairing/removing the shadow on the nearest cabinet) and better perspective in the lower handles. A good effort.