Tough choice, other one a bit boring, my vote go to this one.
Both pretty solid, but this is just a bit more awesome and has some seriously good source manip and usage going on. Cloning could be better up top and it has some weird resizing / aliasing stuff going on; I'm sensing a trend with that. Nonetheless, it gets my vote.
VERY COOL! GOOD LUCK!! SOME VERY NICE AND WELL DONE DETAILS. BUT SOME INTEGRATION WORK NEEDED FOR CAPTAIN HAT, 2 BOTTOM FISHES, BUBBLES AND 2 CHIMNEYS... ALSO PERSPECTIVE OF TOP BARREL AND WATER DOESN'T FIT. 8-)