"Eyed" eat it. :P Love the folds and wrinkles.
Two very good images..I like the unique idea,the humor and composition of this image.
Tough choice! I like the overall design of the other image better (I mean ewww, eye pie? ;p --really, just a mater of taste... so to speak lol), but your subtleties in lighting and the folds / puckers you created impress me enough to take my vote. :)
Nice idea and "wrapping" in the leaf around the lost eye. But the hole that's left looks very strange. Looks like it has been moved to the right and messed up the nose...?