ReinMan
Well... um.... er, ah.... I'll pick "A" for 30 points, Phil. :/
cafn8d
If "showing up is half the battle," you're both half-winners. :P I realize it was a hard source, but :?. While the other image does more with the source, this one is more effective and made me chuckle.
Granulated
the other one comes across as a 'thrown in towel' entry despite its humour and professional sheen. Therefore I have to vote for this one even though there is some clumsy integration.
Pearcinator
Looks like your opponent just couldnt deal with this (very difficult) source. This is great cleanup work though! Very nice...Abonimable Snowman is cool too.