TheShaman
I like the other one a lot, and I'm heavy into space themes... But with that said, this is really good as well... I'm voting here because I can 'see' more source.
billtvshow
Looks like a big source effort in the other entry on the larger spaceship / creature? But the clarity and cleaner chopping in this one outweighs that.
kittie
These are nuts! The source work of the other entry is incredible, but I love the overall idea and finished project of this one too much. Great job to both!
the burning couch
The other is really good work but it confuses me a bit...I think it's the over-all saturation that's a too much. I like this composition and lighting*!
Grefix
At first I was going to vote for the concert one, due to it's clean execution and vibrant colors. But the more I look at this, the more I appreciate the work that was done on it. The Painitng style gives it a bit of a blurry feel but I'm willing to look past that :) Sir, you've got my vote.
bogonet
As I see it, the construction of the mother ship is pretty much source (if im not mistaken) and I like that, also the color, the front ship is a bit distorted/ streched. The other is good too. Another tough game. Coin flip!