Photoshop Contest PhotoshopContest.com
Creative Contests. Real Prizes. Essential Resource.
You are not logged in. Log in or Register

 
Photoshop Contest Head to Head Tournament 2010
pakimo vs CarlC
winner! votes round compare to
pakimo 67 Round #1 original
Winning Image

Voting Details
VoterComment
:-@dolly :-@dolly
...
TheShaman TheShaman
cleaner
DLowrie DLowrie
...
billtvshow billtvshow
The top of the other one is really weird.
Napalm32 Napalm32
...
Tawiskaro Tawiskaro
Again, lots of reconstruction effort in both. The first is somewhat crisper.
Meeshoo Klan Meeshoo Klan
...
TofuTheGreat TofuTheGreat
...
Mel47 Mel47
...
dewking dewking
...
kittie kittie
Nice shadow work, and I like the steam coming from the top.
Sliver Sliver
...
mawaho mawaho
cleanly constructed
Dead Man Dead Man
...
Prince Laurent Prince Laurent
not sure about shadow direction, but my fav.
UntExp UntExp
...
MonkeeDrummer MonkeeDrummer
Too many people just fixing mugs... I'll vote for this one. Good shadow work, the other entry's table top and inside of mug kill it for me.
bigbuck bigbuck
...
jazgraphic jazgraphic
...
Trann Trann
...
Alex Alex
...
Huubbbb Huubbbb
Tough one..this one wins it for me due to the mug.
vokaris vokaris
...
vunt van pumununt vunt van pumununt
...
Krank Krank
...
Sjitske Sjitske
...
CarlC CarlC
Great minds think alike! I tried my best. An honor going up against you.
JORDAN792 JORDAN792
nice
Azionite Azionite
like the illustrated look of this one..
Salvezza Salvezza
nice work
pjsev pjsev
...
Patre Patre
...
dbbowling dbbowling
...
metalic metalic
...
Huni Huni
...
delia delia
Nicer shadow on the other entry, but your clean up of the table was really nice, and they had a smudgy top rim.
bogonet bogonet
...
rett435 rett435
...
Eve Eve
...
Lord David Lord David
...
sirenka sirenka
...
Granulated Granulated
The other one has its good points. The new tiles is not one of them.
Michel Michel
Sighs!
Jake420 Jake420
...
Sh!Za Sh!Za
...
koorio koorio
nice
rashdog rashdog
...
nancers nancers
:)
jorzza jorzza
...
nat_g31 nat_g31
No offense but the lighting is terribly off on the entry. I do think the clean up is well done compared to the other which is a bit muddy.
screwloose screwloose
...
clonestamp trooper clonestamp trooper
...
Oscar Oscar
I'm going to guess here but am going to be seeing a lot of fixed cups.
bneises bneises
...
anabe anabe
clean simplicity
Dechene Dechene
...
Chopper Chopper
...
EJH EJH
...
Eepi Eepi
...
Chris. Chris.
...
ElectronChaser ElectronChaser
...
m0nk m0nk
...
TutorMe TutorMe
...
Carcarlo Carcarlo
...
Doc_isme Doc_isme
...
KENNY CHUNG KENNY CHUNG
...
carmine665 carmine665
...


author votes round compare to
CarlC 66 Round #1 original

Voting Details
VoterComment
kinetic_be kinetic_be
nyxxie nyxxie
Hmm, I'll go with this one. I luv the worn look for the cup.
Tesore Tesore
Nice tiles
janetdog janetdog
good
spencej1129 spencej1129
rose-wood71 rose-wood71
tiles on table made this stand out for me. writing on centre of cup seems not quite right to me.
Mir Mir
Both are good but this one has that little bit more I think.
bogsy bogsy
claudiolky claudiolky
dannyboyuk09 dannyboyuk09
Best of the two (in my opinion)
Cartoon Contractor Cartoon Contractor
Nice rebuild! The other is good but this one is better!
Starman Starman
ReyRey ReyRey
Flips coin......You win
Heinlein Heinlein
spikelmalo spikelmalo
pakimo pakimo
Well done :)
blue_lurker blue_lurker
both good a little more effort went into this one
Hagen Hagen
Good work here...! Nice idea changing the tiles...! The cup might need some more work though...!
Watch them Drift Watch them Drift
not a fan of the table but the other one has too many lighting issues, not that yours doesn't but its the better of the two.
TJ TJ
woobie woobie
buglover buglover
mikey mikey
ihaveissues ihaveissues
volkswes volkswes
rockfisch rockfisch
Tommeken Tommeken
damn ugly tiles man..but stil nice work ;)
seelcraft seelcraft
Both created the tiles from other sources or PS, probably smarter than patching them. This one has a truer restoration of the cup, although the front lip is distorted.
Sanctuary Sanctuary
...
Mid Mid
j58roldan j58roldan
nevet nevet
NButler NButler
JAM JAM
deshone deshone
...
Tad Tad
YerPalAl YerPalAl
Rim is a little problematical, but nice work in general.
anfa anfa
ReinMan ReinMan
nice tiles!
Janfet Janfet
:-)
marcoballistic marcoballistic
A tight one too, I like the crispness of the other, but this has more, the new all source clever tiles are good, and I like the rutic look to the mug, contrasts well with the table
thbeghin thbeghin
;)
supak0ma supak0ma
just because the other cup is hovering, the top part of the cup is hideous
DaVinci DaVinci
Both same idea, not very original but I like this one better...
nifft nifft
nifft nifft
the burning couch the burning couch
Good reconstruct*!
BroChris BroChris
nice
MamaBallistic MamaBallistic
Love the idea of using the source for the tile pattern! Take more time on your cut outs though. The other entry hasn't optimised the source as you have hence my vote.
glennhanna glennhanna
Put this cup on your opponent's table, and you've got the best of both chops. The patterns on this cup match the original better relative to size and space, although it appears a little on the thin side.
kbuzz818 kbuzz818
nice new table design, that set's yours apart from the ordinary
Tea Man Tea Man
Pearcinator Pearcinator
The better of the two cleanups. Still not perfect though.
Goat1981 Goat1981
perspective is wonky in the other
jazpur jazpur
jefflang007 jefflang007
L@rue L@rue
abraham abraham
sonic3 sonic3
charliesou charliesou
bsoholic bsoholic
cafn8d cafn8d
I like the new design of the other cup better, but the pattern chosen for the countertop and having it flipped around made this one just a bit more interesting to me. :) Good job to both!
Cambria Cambria
soulrock soulrock
Claf Claf
mellowdesign mellowdesign
Mug needs work esp. rim...but like what you did with the tiles


« Go to previous match - back to tournament - Go to next match »
Navigate PSC
Contests active  archives  winners  prizes  sponsors  events  rules  rss 
Galleries votes  authentic  skillful  funny  creative  theme  winners 
Interact register  log in/out  forum  chat  user lookup  contact 
Stats monthly leaders  hall of fame  record holders 
PSC advantage  news  (rss)  faq  about  links  contact  home 
Help faq  search  new users  tutorials  contact  password 

Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright � 2000-2024 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved.
A venture of ExpertRating.com

PSC Time 9:02 pm EST