Photoshop Contest PhotoshopContest.com
Creative Contests. Real Prizes. Essential Resource.
You are not logged in. Log in or Register

 
Photoshop Contest Head to Head Tournament 2011
volkswes vs captainSMITTY11
winner! votes round compare to
captainSMITTY11 97 Round #3 original
Winning Image

Voting Details
VoterComment
volkswes volkswes
NICE!! I like the happy tractor
Takser3 Takser3
...
deshone deshone
nice !
Dechene Dechene
...
annajon annajon
very good, would hang this on my wall
bc2013 bc2013
...
nevet nevet
...
Napalm32 Napalm32
...
Hagen Hagen
Not sure but I think this is CaptainSMITTY's work...! I like the overall composition better here than in the other chop...! Yet the execution is better on the other one...! Really a tough choice...! +1
jasper jasper
nice feel and employment of tilt-shift.
dewking dewking
...
Designed2522 Designed2522
THIS IS AWESOME!!!
ReinMan ReinMan
BOTH of these entries ROCK. Very cool indeed. Smart "interpretation" of the source photo. This one gets my vote as I'm a sucker for Depth of Focus in a composition... and also that crazy STEPHEN KING POSSESSED TRACTOR threatening in the background is nice. The only thing that makes this seem unreal is that everyone knows a baby would NEVER RISK ITS LIFE FOR A FRICKIN APPLE! (well, maybe if it was an iPAD2)
mikey mikey
...
TJ TJ
...
charliesou charliesou
...
anfa anfa
...
bud1121 bud1121
both nice but this 1 stands out for me
Ivan Roujev Ivan Roujev
...
billtvshow billtvshow
Talk about two solid entries. I hope people don't get entirely hung up on the lack of source material in the other one. I once did an entry where I did virtually the same thing with foam pellets and bees and won the contest. It is a valid and well done chop. That said, the effort and feel of this image is magnificent. Inconsistent apple sizes aside, this is my fave thus far.
Krank Krank
...
seelcraft seelcraft
Good composition. The perspective on the turned blocks is too extreme.
Patre Patre
...
tadams tadams
Very creative. Not sure about the lens flare.
Luckdeezybb22 Luckdeezybb22
...
Rangizzz Rangizzz
:)
ElectronChaser ElectronChaser
Another difficult choice. I love both of these entries.
DaVinci DaVinci
...
Heinlein Heinlein
...
StoneDigidy StoneDigidy
...
koorio koorio
both are fantastic entries.. this one is wonderful of course. the other is cool but something in it is missing.. I dont know.
supak0ma supak0ma
too many perspective issues in the other one, here some d.o.f. mishaps etc. but still a better chop
jonjon jonjon
...
Tad Tad
...
badcop badcop
love
crmzendrgone crmzendrgone
...
Death of a Clown Death of a Clown
Nice job.
gramps gramps
...
Netwel Netwel
cool
Jake420 Jake420
hard choice I just like this better
HienTran HienTran
...
zoli22 zoli22
...
JORDAN792 JORDAN792
some proportion and perspective issues but great reference on the source, one of the hardest match ups for me, other is great
Eve Eve
...
ReyRey ReyRey
...
digimagicnb digimagicnb
Apple search-off; even though the other is pretty, the use of source is rather too subtle, so this wins for good use of blocks even though it has some issues
TheShaman TheShaman
Tough choice. like this one just a bit better. reminds me of the I-Spy books
sonic3 sonic3
Like this
Tommeken Tommeken
sweet...difficult choice tough..other one is nice to (and they both got a red apple in it :p )
locxoul locxoul
...
jcfreak6363 jcfreak6363
...
serious serious
...
screwloose screwloose
Both are Great!
gsenthil gsenthil
nice job
Oscar Oscar
...
edovan edovan
...
pakimo pakimo
...
stroban stroban
...
Martrex Martrex
Both are great, how to decide, flipped a coin.
Zetape Zetape
...
Tesore Tesore
...
glennhanna glennhanna
tough choice. I actually like this use of tilt shift
nat_g31 nat_g31
Great matchup! This image could be my favorite of the round. fuckin awesome! I hope youll share the psd with me! As for the other I love the idea but the execution could have been a bit more crisp.
digitalpharaoh digitalpharaoh
...
bogsy bogsy
...
the burning couch the burning couch
*!
MikeDascola MikeDascola
You both did awesome. Good luck!!
Cartoon Contractor Cartoon Contractor
...
Pearcinator Pearcinator
Tough vote...but the crates win it for me. Very well done. The other entry is also quite good but theres something off with the white fence thingy in the top right corner that puts me off...
Tawiskaro Tawiskaro
...
Meeshoo Klan Meeshoo Klan
...
thbeghin thbeghin
:)
blindgod blindgod
...
16ozBud 16ozBud
...
x,sylvia x,sylvia
...
Robiin33 Robiin33
...
tpsimer tpsimer
like the crates
TofuTheGreat TofuTheGreat
Love the tilt shifting going on.
UntExp UntExp
...
monkeytwig monkeytwig
...
anabe anabe
...
buglover buglover
prefer this cause of the illustrative style
Sh!Za Sh!Za
...
Azionite Azionite
my fav of the comp!
bogonet bogonet
...
Mel47 Mel47
...
Sleepyeyed Sleepyeyed
...
woodie woodie
...
bneises bneises
...
j58roldan j58roldan
...
rockyjob rockyjob
like this one a bit more
Tea Man Tea Man
going this way for the tractor lulz
cafn8d cafn8d
Hard choice; I like them both! But I can relate to this one more. LOL! ;)
KENNY CHUNG KENNY CHUNG
...
Salvezza Salvezza
...
L@rue L@rue
...
GuidedByPandas GuidedByPandas
...


author votes round compare to
volkswes 34 Round #3 original

Voting Details
VoterComment
Lord David Lord David
Sliver Sliver
This was my toughest choice, I'll go with this one due to its originality.. other entry is great as well!
vokaris vokaris
Tough choice. Congratulations to both contestants for the efforts.
metalic metalic
Eepi Eepi
kevindey kevindey
lighting is a bit off, but I really like this idea. the other is also an original idea. tough choice.
roger1 roger1
delia delia
Swarhzonov Swarhzonov
YerPalAl YerPalAl
captainSMITTY11 captainSMITTY11
great idea! kicked my ass i think but this was definitely a good match up like i thought. had either of us been paired with a different person we probably would have won hands down but this makes it exciting. Best of luck great work here :)
Trann Trann
Both of these are very good! I love the depth of field in the other; a few crates have perspective/scale issues and maybe all blocks should have been changed to complete things. In this, resetting the scene works pretty well: nice lighting/shadows; the bright flowers/lone leaves are a bit too stark but good effort overall!
drybie drybie
Different isn't always good but in this case it is. Although there are things that maybe I would have omitted or changed like the apple or the fence, the idea wins me over. The other has apple issues too, but I'm just not sure what's going on there.
nifft nifft
hard choice
the202 the202
NButler NButler
gravyboat gravyboat
Nice. :)
Ammorio Ammorio
not easy to choose . but i like this one much better.
bsoholic bsoholic
abraham abraham
EJH EJH
Synthvet Synthvet
GhostlyJoe GhostlyJoe
dsclink dsclink
aman aman
nice , the satellite view.... :)
dbbowling dbbowling
nice work
Goat1981 Goat1981
This is the first time I used a coin flip to determine which image to vote for... Both images are pretty equal in my mind. I love the idea here and the chopping is superb (with some very minor lighting problems), but the original source is gone (besides hints with the placement of the blocks, leaves, apple, cat, etc.). The other does more with the source and also has a great idea but the perspective of the boxes is erratic. Both minor flaws. Congratulations to both; wish I could vote for both. *lol* This one won the flip.
Sanctuary Sanctuary
hmph love the cat... i like the other too but this perspective got my eye.
tdiddy tdiddy
Dream_weaver Dream_weaver
Claf Claf
Excellent match! I prefer this composition. Very nice! Maybe the white fence is too clean & too strong contrast.
betdoval betdoval
Grefix Grefix
I can't give anymore comment, because each comment just makes me swing back from the one to the other. My last swing was here. Toughest choice of all games. Congrats to the both of you
Mir Mir
both good this one bit more thinking outside the box.


« Go to previous match - back to tournament - Go to next match »
Navigate PSC
Contests active  archives  winners  prizes  sponsors  events  rules  rss 
Galleries votes  authentic  skillful  funny  creative  theme  winners 
Interact register  log in/out  forum  chat  user lookup  contact 
Stats monthly leaders  hall of fame  record holders 
PSC advantage  news  (rss)  faq  about  links  contact  home 
Help faq  search  new users  tutorials  contact  password 

Adobe, the Adobe logo, Adobe Photoshop, Creative Suite and Illustrator are registered trademarks of Adobe Systems Incorporated.
Text and images copyright 2000-2022 Photoshop Contest. All rights reserved.
A venture of ExpertRating.com

PSC Time 7:28 pm EST